Identifying Clinically Meaningful Tools for Measuring Comfort Perception of Footwear. Mills K, Blanch P, Vicenzino B.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2010 Mar 8. [Epub ahead of print]
Interesting,
In Quebec City, we are in the process to investigate comfort (stand-up, walking, running). The client is blind (covering sheet on top of the different shoe)… and test different shoes with different minimalist index (TRC rating) -no just big bulky shoe-
The tendency for the moment is:
1. They prefer more minimal shoes
2. that are not to far from their habits
It seems that this perception persist after for longer run...
Shoe and orthotic comfort has always been difficult to test and even more dificult to prove.
One attribute i rarely see in shoe comfort ratings is how comfortable they are on the lower extreamity,
lower back and body as a whole.
They often tend to focus on the comfort of the foot not the whole body that is being affected by the function (or lack of fuction ie minimalism)
of the orthosis/footwear.
I suppose similar findings are found in the sports equipment industry such as with backpack comfort and other pieces of needed gear. I know the best way to test our
combat boots and shoes is on a long run.
Things start to feel a little different at mile 16 and again at 26. And it is amazing how many things just go away in the end as you run through them and how many things that did not seem like a problem on the run become so a day or two afterward.
It would have been nice to see the additional condition of barefoot running in this study but test runners may have some issue with that and you cannot force study subjects to do something they consider dangerous or harmful without assuring and proving it to them otherwise. You also are responsible if they do get hurt.
Definition and evaluation of plantar mechanical comfort for the support of footwear design
Charlie C.L. Wang, Chinese University of Hong Kong, and Yunbo Zhang Computer-Aided Design and Applications
Intra-rater reliability of footwear-related comfort assessments
Stefan Hoerzer, Matthieu B. Trudeau, W. Brent Edwards & Benno M. Nigg Footwear Science: 08 Jul 2016
Aloha,
This is a good reason why human subject testing of footwear and orthotic therapies should be held off until further biomechanical testing is done by purely mechanical means.
Asking our patients if the "pills" we give them are tasty and easy to swallow does affect compliance but if it results in reducing the effectiveness of the treatment modality what good have we done?
Shoe comfort is not condition for Gait Maximalism.
Maximalism must prove significant improvements of safety, stability, energy efficiency and Greenability.
The running shoe comfort assessment tool (RUN-CAT): Development and evaluation of a new multi-item assessment tool for evaluating the comfort of running footwear
Christopher Bishop et al Journal of Sports Sciences: 06 Jun 2020
Perception of footwear comfort and its relationship with the foot structure among youngest-old women and men.
Puszczalowska-Lizis E, Koziol K, Omorczyk J PeerJ 9:e12385 https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.12385
Perception of footwear comfort and its relationship with the foot structure among youngest-old women and men
Ewa Puszczalowska-Lizis et al PeerJ. 2021 Oct 19;9:e12385
Monitoring the Degree of Comfort of Shoes In-Motion Using Triboelectric Pressure Sensors with an Ultrawide Detection Range
Peng Yang
et al ACS Nano. 2022 Feb 16