Members do not see these Ads. Sign Up.

I have heard two opposing opinions on what type of running shoe is ideal to pair with orthotics. One opinion I have heard is to pair an antipronation orthotic with a "cushion" shoe. This is to allow the orthotic to do the work and not to over control the foot and have better comfort. The other opinion is to pair the orthotic with a shoe that fits the foot type regardless (i.e. a maximal motion control shoe with a severe overpronator or moderate motion control shoe with a moderate overpronator etc.) So what is best? Can anyone speak on how the same orthotic works on a cushion shoe bed versus a motion control shoe bed?

 

Clearly the issues are complex, you should read the "shank dependent thread" it will increase your understanding of the issues. The net result of shoe and orthosis is the big question....and what net result are you looking for in a particular individual?....Having played with ski boots, hiking boots and shoes and orthoses for years I don't think there is one correct answer to your question. I can tell you that for twenty plus years people have been trying to take the need for experience, expertise and attention to detail out of the process....computers, scanners, quick fix books etc.....and this just won't do it for the hard ones.....you need eyes, ears, experience, brains, education and good judgement.....sorry to have to break it to you so harshly....
regards Phill Carter

 

Obviously a stiffer, harder midsole/shoe will influence how rigidly the orthoses sit under the foot.....put them on and feel it for yourself.....the activity being undertaken will also influence what combination of shape and materials can be tolerated by the foot.....rigid alpine ski boots done up too tight....vs sloppy skate board shoes.......rollerblades......basketball boots......high jump spikes......lots of variables here.....and each needs working out for a particular individual in relation to their problems and foot sensitivity.
regards Phill Carter

 

Well said Phil!
The type of shoe in conjunction with an orthosis is an individual thing- you judge each person and the orthosis and what your aims are.. then assess the most appropriate type of shoe for them.

 

We so over that difference!!
See these two threads:
Do “cushioning” shoes really cushion impacts?
What do we mean by 'motion control' in running shoes

and also this thread:
Orthoses within a neutral running shoe or within a support running shoe?