Welcome to the Podiatry Arena forums

You are currently viewing our podiatry forum as a guest which gives you limited access to view all podiatry discussions and access our other features. By joining our free global community of Podiatrists and other interested foot health care professionals you will have access to post podiatry topics (answer and ask questions), communicate privately with other members, upload content, view attachments, receive a weekly email update of new discussions, access other special features. Registered users do not get displayed the advertisements in posted messages. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our global Podiatry community today!

  1. Everything that you are ever going to want to know about running shoes: Running Shoes Boot Camp Online, for taking it to the next level? See here for more.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Have you considered the Critical Thinking and Skeptical Boot Camp, for taking it to the next level? See here for more.
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Have you considered the Clinical Biomechanics Boot Camp Online, for taking it to the next level? See here for more.
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Have you considered the Clinical Biomechanics Boot Camp Online, for taking it to the next level? See here for more.
Dismiss Notice
Have you liked us on Facebook to get our updates? Please do. Click here for our Facebook page.
Dismiss Notice
Do you get the weekly newsletter that Podiatry Arena sends out to update everybody? If not, click here to organise this.

Should doctors treat lack of exercise as a medical condition?

Discussion in 'Break Room' started by NewsBot, Aug 13, 2012.

Tags:
  1. NewsBot

    NewsBot The Admin that posts the news.

    Articles:
    1

    Members do not see these Ads. Sign Up.
    Press Release:
    Should doctors treat lack of exercise as a medical condition? Mayo expert says 'yes'
     
  2. BEN-HUR

    BEN-HUR Well-Known Member

    Good article. Views of which are well overdue. Lack of exercise & poor diet are the two major causes/influences of diseases. Not partaking in exercise & eating whatever tastes good go hand in hand & conveniently provides an environment of keeping people within their comfort zone... having major adverse implications on the cardiovascular system & the digestive system; providing an internal environment for disease (i.e. high acidity). Is it any wonder that there is so much disease/cancer out there... & genes play a very small role... hence it is simply poor (lazy) lifestyle choices.

    We as Podiatrists should be well aware of this being that systemic conditions usually have implications on the lower limb hence why they visit or have been referred to us. I always try to put across the importance of exercise & appropriate food choices to my patients. Some give me a glazed look, some don't want to hear it, for some it goes through one ear & out the other & some consider an alternative... as their current lifestyle hasn't done them much good as far as health & vitality is concerned.

    I usually say... "you are more likely to rust out than wear out" after they question the need (or provide an excuse) to exercise. There really does need to be another National campaign on this topic... once again, as people have very little idea (&/or forget)... like there was when I was a young child - "Life Be In It” (Australia)...



    I know there is one showing at the moment (i.e. balloon man) from time to time but it really needs more substance.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 22, 2016
  3. davidh

    davidh Podiatry Arena Veteran

    Not exercising clearly isn't a medical condition.
    It may be stupid, but thats as far as it goes. Unless stupid is also a medical condition.

    Obesity is a medical condition. Diabetes is a medical condition. Not exercising is down to poor education about normal body requirements.
     
  4. Lab Guy

    Lab Guy Well-Known Member

    Not exercising is a poor choice. Poor choices lead to medical conditions.

    Steven
     
  5. drsha

    drsha Banned

    I usually say...

    Rusting Out.... I love it

    Do I quote you as coining it?

    Dennis
     
  6. LSM

    LSM Welcome New Poster

    I often despair at the natural inclination of the human species to slothfulness. I have sat in many Public Health forums, designed to look at ways we can increase the incidental exercise of the community. My fellow attendees often a group of soft, middle-aged, busy health workers who have driven to the meeting, work long hours and get no exercise themselves try to make our communities more exercise friendly. On these occaissions I challenge those at the meeting to advise how much exercise they have managed themselves in the last week. There is often an embarrassed silence- It is as if the changes they expect of the "public" is for some other class of people not themselves.

    I am not sure how we reverse the trend- behavioral change should be part of the tool box of every health worker, assiting patients self efficacy in regard to exercise is very important
     
  7. BEN-HUR

    BEN-HUR Well-Known Member

    I think we all here should know that “lack of exercise” in & of itself isn’t a medical condition... just like smoking in & of itself isn’t a medical condition & continually eating junk food isn’t a medical condition in & of itself... but the ramifications of these popular lifestyle choices have far reaching adverse health problems (costing billions of dollars & much pain) that need to put into the equation of optimal medical treatment... as they have clear correlation to the likes of obesity, CVD, diabetes etc...
    "Lack of exercise" is probably not held in the same light as the more established/regarded poor lifestyle choices such as smoking... hence the article & the alarmist title.

    It may seems like common sense for some but one thing we can all probably agree on is that this type of "sense" isn’t all that "common" at all... hence to get to the crux of the issue maybe we can also put “common sense” into the equation also (then we also cross over into psychology/psychiatry).

    Hi Dennis, no I certainly can’t say I coined the phrase. I thought it was a rather popular phrase – probably more so within the mechanical world than the physiology world. Yet the same/similar principles apply here with us humans. Another phrase closely associated with the... "you are more likely to rust out than wear out" would be... “if you don’t use it you will lose it” which is probably more popular phrase within the physiology realm.
     
  8. Excerise should be a module in out training package, just being able to provide simple exercise packages similar to what physiotherapists provide, suitable for each person or conditions presented would help mobility as many older patients simply give up or forgot what they can achieve..
     
  9. drsha

    drsha Banned

    Tracy:
    Very powerful dreams you have.
    But do you have direction and applications for your dreams and are they being fostered by tissue stress biomechanics, the current EBM or, dare I say it, The Podiatry Arena faithful?

    What if there was a system where your patients could be profiled and classified one of a subgroup of foot types as a starting platform in practice for custom care instead of whatever you currently perform?

    What if instead of the hodgepodge of biomechanics language which is difficult to understand or teach to others, someone reworked it into a communication set that could be better understood and taught to the masses and sophisticated scientists and researchers alike?

    What if once you diagnose a patients subset, as a practitioner with skill to customize a program of closed chain care, you selected an optimal functional position for casting an orthotic shell along with a foot type specific starting menu of postings, cutouts and other ORF's for providing that custom care?

    What if you then, presented the patient with I or II Levels of Compensatory Threshold Training that would train their supporting and powering lower extremity muscles using custom MERF's that fostered Wolf's and Davis' Laws to "reverse" developmental biomechanical changes the same way they developed?

    What if you demonstrated and then monitored that program, like the physiotherapists in your dream?

    What if you then educated and partnered with MD's, PT's, Chiro's, exercise trainers, yoga practitioners, etc in your community with whom you could cross refer in order to take your patients to an even higher level of your dreams with even better outcomes?

    What if you had marketing tools like posters/brochures/pamphlets and well thought out hand-outs to educate patients, the MD community and the foot and postural suffering public as to what you are capable of doing and why they should seek your care?

    What if you patented and trademarked this plan so that others couldn't dilute/bastardize or imitate it allowing it to grow and thrive, be researched and be promoted to maximize its health benefits to mankind? :drinks

    What if it was also, as a sidebar, a profitable plan? :craig:

    Would you send me a cast? :rolleyes:

    Dennis
     
  10. efuller

    efuller MVP

    What if you bottled some snake oil and made up a bunch of wonderful things that the snake oil could do. Just drink it and don't ask any questions. Someone will make some money.

    Eric
     
  11. Just for you, Eric.....;)
     
  12. efuller

    efuller MVP

    Thanks, Kevin.
    I'm pretty sure that my contracted cords would feel better after drinking the snake oil than if I sent Dennis a cast. He still hasn't said what he'd do differently with that cast.
     
  13. wdd

    wdd Well-Known Member

    I think that rather than trying to answer this particular question the debate should be enlarged to include more general questions on the topic of medicalisation.

    What is the function of medicine? What can be medicalised? How does something become medicalised? What are the individual advantages /disadvantages of medicalisation? What are the alternatives to medicalisation? What are the advantages/disadvantages for the medical profession of increasing medicalisation?

    In France, if you want to play any sport competitively you must be insured. Before you can be insured you must be healthy enough to play in competitions. Who decides whether or not you can play your sport competitively? Your doctor of course.

    Is this form of social control necessary? Is it good for the individual or for society?Is it an intrusion upon the liberty of the individual, eg if I am prepared to take the chance of having a heart attack while I am playing football should I be allowed to? Are doctors able to predict the risks so accurately that they can reasonably make these decisions?

    Bill
     
  14. Lachw89

    Lachw89 Welcome New Poster

    I think this is the first serious post I have made, so I hope it's of at least some use!

    My biggest problem that I have with medicalising things like lack of exercise is that I would imagine it turns something that one afflicts oneself with (through poor habits/discipline) into something that one is afflicted WITH (by fate etc).... Although I have never taken one of these patients myself I have had a good chuckle hearing from people who's patients 'have obesity' in the same way that they might pick up a common cold, or be born with blue eyes. It would almost appear the understanding of their condiation has a complete removal of cause from affect!!

    By medicalising lack of exercise, I could only imagine that more and more people will simply feel that their lack of drive is not something that they themselves can control, but something that requires counselling, pharmacotherapeutics or whatever ends up being the way they decide to go. Of course, good practitioners always try to involve the patient in whatever way they can in therapies but I would fear that even so, self responsibility would decrease in a lot of individuals if it became a 'Medical Diagnosis'

    As far as the argument that says medicalising it will better allow us to treat it.....
    We are already encouraging patients to maintain fitness and assisting them in whatever capacity we can as Podiatrists, we already have dietitians and PTs and medical practitioners specialising in fitness readily available to the public and we already have the Public health sector going overtime educating people about how healthy exercise is. There are plenty of aspects about this system that need working on, sure, but the fact is if people don't have the discipline and desire to go and use these resources, how on earth are they going to sustain the effort required for a lifetime of healthy living, particularly if their situations change and shock horror things get MORE difficult?

    Enough of this (probably naive and perhaps a little too unsympathetic) rant.... simply said I feel that medicalising lack of exercise will do just that, make it OUR problem and even less of their's than it is now.
     
  15. Catfoot

    Catfoot Well-Known Member

    All,
    I thought exercise was covered in the Pod Degree Uni course under Biomechanics or am I mis-informed ?

    All the pods I have worked with are able to suggest simple therapeutic exercises for clients

    regards

    Catfoot
     
  16. drsha

    drsha Banned

    Lachw89:
    Your posting certainly has value for me.

    I took the liberty to right click on words in your post that have a red underlining to correct spellling (right click on spellling to correct) of recognized words as you create, edit or quote them. Once you click submit, the red underlinings disappear and your posting suffers.
    That leaves you with words that are red underlined that are not recognized as words like medicalising (which is your attempt to get a word that clarifies a concept that needs better defining and deserves to be printed here on The Arena). This includes biomechanics, PT's and pharmacotherapeutics as well as SALRE and dorsiflectory or plantarflectory (as in stiffness).

    In general, The Arena allows these red underlined acronyms, new words and currently unaccepted words that one is trying to get accepted that relate to their agenda and deride others that ability as they bully or defame those with opposing views them off the site (witness the infantile snake oil stuff on this thread). So be prepared to be personally bombarded by the same 6-7 posters if your philosophy, work or theories don't conform.

    That said, I have years of anecdotal clinical success and as a blogger setting up and calling for networking partnerships with or without walls that comprise a biomechanically oriented podiatrist, a lower extremity specialized foot and ankle surgeon (DPM or MD) and a therapist with expertise in functional lower extremity prehab and rehab and in compensatory threshold training (physical therapist, yoga practitioner, Pilates trainer, exercise therapist or trainer, chiropractor) under the umbrella of Wellness Biomechanics

    This team can then each function as primary or consultation performers and as a team provide a Custom foundational platform for the exercise pillar of a structured fitness/diet/medical health tripod medicalisation program.

    I prefer to think that I am leading an Acculturation or Socialization of Biomechanics.


    Dennis
     
  17. Lack of exercise is no more a medical condition than eating junk food is a medical condition. However, since exercise has been known for decades to be therapeutically beneficial with a minimum of side effects, then not exercising regularly will increase the health risk of certain pathologies for individuals.

    Even though we, as podiatrists, are only legally allowed to treat a certain area of the human body, as healthcare professionals we are still responsible for the general well-being of our patients. In that regard, we need to inform our patients of the health risks that they face by making poor lifestyle choices such as exercising too little (or too much) or eating the wrong foods (or too much).

    My practice philosophy is that if I can prescribe something that has the greatest amount of potential therapeutic benefits with the least amount of potential detrimental side effects and also costs nothing or very little, then I am providing a valuable service by recommending this to my patients. That is why I discuss the importance of exercise with nearly all my patients since, when done regularly, it improves both physical and mental health, causes very few side effects and is inexpensive. I feel that is part of my job as a healthcare provider that has taken an oath to try to heal the individuals who seek my medical expertise. Podiatrists need to be part of this healthcare team that strongly recommends the benefits of regular exercise to our patients for the benefit of their health and well-being. If you are not already doing this as a podiatrist, then, in my opinion, you are not doing enough for your patients.

    Is lack of exercise a medical condition? No. But lack of exercise, will, over time, increase the risk of medical conditions developing that will ultimately injure, cause pathology or decrease the quality of life of the individual. We, as podiatrists, need to see to it that our patients understand the many health benefits of regular exercise so they can be properly informed of the best lifestyle choices for their health and continued well-being.

     
  18. BEN-HUR

    BEN-HUR Well-Known Member

    Yes, good point - I do likewise.

    I think the following cartoon is quite appropriate for this thread... maybe I could use something similar, strategically placed in my waiting room ;)... not sure how that would go down though :rolleyes:.... :sinking:

    [​IMG]

    Oh, what the heck... I'll just do it.... :boohoo:
     
  19. wdd

    wdd Well-Known Member

    Obesity, cigarette smoking, high cholesterol and high blood pressure are all medicalised so why not add lack of exercise to the list.

    Should we also medicalise poverty?

    As the size of the medical domain increases does the political power of medicine increase proportionately? Is it a good thing?

    The increasing sphere of influence of medicine, associated with the move from treating frank disease to treating the causes of disease, ie preventative medicine, is problematic and needs discussion.

    Is preventative medicine a good thing full stop or does it need parameters?

    Bill
     
  20. NewsBot

    NewsBot The Admin that posts the news.

    Articles:
    1
    Press Release:
    Couch-potato kids are biggest child health problem in the U.S., adults say
    ‘Not enough exercise’ cited as top children’s health concern, obesity second, according to U-M’s National Poll on Children’s Health annual top 10 list
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 22, 2016
  21. drsha

    drsha Banned

    This debate in the U.S. is largely controlled by the insurance companies, the pharm industry and the government in the sense that if these mega-powers choose not to fund or pay for prevention, performance enhancement and quality of life upgrading, then the only way one can get them is to pay out-of-pocket.

    Prevention is future thinking and the CEO's and politico's are more interested in the next quarter or election.

    EBM has become a means by which these groups can refuse payment or services as prevention is difficult to prove if at all.

    Salutogenesis vs. Pathogenesis, Wellness vs. Get Sickness and Homeopathy vs Allopathy are buzzwords that divide and polarize the sides like so many other issues.

    The bottom line is that we, the doctors, are not in control of the future of this debate, even though we are at its heart and soul.

    My leanings have changed from the latter to the former as I have matured. Where do you live?
     
  22. wdd

    wdd Well-Known Member

    Like you my leanings have changed as I have aged (matured might be a bridge too far for me). However as it seems to me that as it is in the interest of business and medicine to maintain or exacerbate levels of inactivity and obesity, with the individual playing a role somewhere between a victim and a cash cow, that only leaves government to do something about the problem? In western world governments where does the power balance lie between government and business and within governments where does the power blanace lie between national interest and self interest?

    More and more I see decreasing physical activity and growing obesity as indicators of the success of runaway capitalism. The operative word is 'runaway'.

    Born in Scotlan and lived a large part of my working life in England and now live in France.


    Best wishes,

    Bill
     
  23. wdd

    wdd Well-Known Member

    I think a little professional self-interest is called for here.

    Why should medicine be the only profession to gain from the advancing obesity pandemic?

    How about seeding the idea that obesity is the result of 'excessive' subtalar joint pronation and that normal body weight can be attained, without effort, by visiting a podiatrist and buying a pair of orthoses - preferably a new pair every six months?

    Fat chance!

    Bill
     
Loading...

Share This Page